TapLearn

Column subtraction with exchanging ("borrowing"): how it works

Quick answer

Column subtraction means writing the bigger number on top, lining up the columns, and subtracting from the right. When the top digit is too small, one ten is exchanged for ten ones from the next column. That used to be called "borrowing"; schools now say "exchanging" because the value stays the same, it is just regrouped.

Also called: the column method, formal written method of subtraction, decomposition, borrowing (now called exchanging)

Practise it in a game

When children learn it

Year 3: subtract numbers with up to three digits using the formal written method of column subtraction. Year 4: up to four digits. Year 5: numbers with more than four digits.

How it works

  1. Write the larger number on top and the smaller number underneath, lining up ones, tens and hundreds.
  2. Start with the ones. If the top digit is big enough, subtract and write the answer.
  3. If the top digit is too small, go to the next column on the left: cross out its digit, write one less, and add ten to the column you're working on. This is exchanging.
  4. Subtract that column, then move left and repeat.
  5. If the next column is a zero, exchange from further left first: a hundred becomes ten tens, then one of those tens becomes ten ones.

Worked example

      4 12 12
    H  T  O
    5  3  2
  - 1  7  8
  ---------
    3  5  4

532 − 178: 2 − 8 can't be done, so exchange a ten (12 − 8 = 4). Then 2 tens − 7 tens can't be done, so exchange a hundred (12 − 7 = 5). Then 4 − 1 = 3. The answer is 354.

The usual mix-ups

  • Taking the smaller digit from the bigger one whatever its position (writing 2 − 8 as 6).
  • Exchanging but forgetting to make the next column one less.
  • Getting stuck on zeros, as in 400 − 128. Exchange from the hundreds first.
  • Putting the smaller number on top.

How to help at home

  • Check every answer with column addition: 354 + 178 should give 532.
  • Use coins (£1, 10p and 1p) to act out an exchange: swap a 10p for ten 1p coins.
  • Ask "is the top number big enough?" before each column.
  • Practise subtracting across zeros on its own, once the basic exchange is secure.

Practise it: game chapters that teach it

Each one opens the game at the chapter that teaches it, with Flip explaining step by step.

Start playing for free: free games open in full, and the first chapter of every other game is free. Membership opens every chapter.

Questions parents ask

Is "decomposition" the same thing?

Yes. Decomposition is the older name for column subtraction with exchanging: you decompose (break up) a ten or a hundred into smaller units.

Why not just teach it the way I learned it?

Some parents learned "borrow and pay back", which puts the ten in a different place. It gives the same answer, but two different methods side by side can confuse a child, so it helps to use the school's way.

What about subtracting from numbers with zeros, like 1,000 − 1?

Exchange step by step from the left: a thousand becomes ten hundreds, one hundred becomes ten tens, one ten becomes ten ones. Or, for numbers like this, counting on (on a number line) is often quicker and is a perfectly good method.

Written by the TapLearn team for parents and carers in England, from the national curriculum programmes of study. Schools choose their own calculation and phonics policies, so your child's school may lay a method out a little differently: use the way their teacher shows them.